This post may contain affiliate links which won’t change your price but will share some commission.

|

Spaghetti Sauce for Canning Made with Fresh (or Frozen) Tomatoes

ByLaurie Neverman

Sharing is caring!

My husband came in from outside the first time I was canning spaghetti sauce, smiled and said the house smelled like an Italian restaurant – a good Italian restaurant. I had to agree.

This sauce takes a while to cook, but the end result is delicious! It's great for pasta, pizza or topping spaghetti squash. Gluten free and meatless (you can add meat just before serving if you like).

homemade spaghetti sauce ready for canning

We take you through the recipe step by step with photos, plus share tips for working with frozen tomatoes, and a print friendly version of the recipe at the bottom of the post.A good homemade spaghetti sauce recipe for canning is a must in our house, because many store bought spaghetti sauces use ingredients like genetically modified high fructose corn syrup and soybean oil – not things we normally eat.

I start a batch in the morning, and slow cook it while I'm working on other things in the kitchen, like prepping the rest of the ingredients and canning equipment. Paste tomatoes yield a thicker sauce with less cooking, but you can use any tomatoes that you have available.

NOTE:  Unlike plain tomato sauce, you do need to use a pressure canner  for canning this spaghetti sauce recipe, since it contains low acid ingredients like oil and onions. See “How to Can Food at Home – Quick Guide to Safe Home Canning” for a review of the basics.

The homemade spaghetti sauce recipes with lemon juice added to make them safe for water bath canning taste like lemons to me, not tomatoes. I've tried them, but I can't recommend them.

Spaghetti Sauce Recipe for Canning with Fresh Tomatoes – Step By Step Instructions

(Scroll down to bottom of post for print friendly version of recipe.)

My favorite canning spaghetti sauce recipe is adapted from The Encyclopedia of Country Living by Carla Emery. This recipe is very close to the“Spaghetti sauce without Meat” recipe listed on the National Center for Home Food Preservation website, so you know it's a safe canning recipe.

Salt and pepper can be adjusted to taste. It's okay to substitute an equal amount of fresh basil for some of the celery, green peppers or mushrooms.

You can also cut this spaghetti sauce recipe in half or to a fourth. Just keep the processing time the same, or freeze the marinara sauce in freezer bags or freezer safe containers instead of canning.

When we're ready to serve the spaghetti sauce, we open a jar and heat it up, or brown some ground beef or Italian sausage and add the sauce to the skillet.

Ingredients

  • 30 pounds tomatoes
  • 1/4 cup butter or olive oil
  • 1 cup chopped onions
  • 5 minced garlic cloves
  • 2 tablespoons salt
  • 1 cup chopped celery or green pepper
  • 1 pound sliced mushrooms (optional)
  • 2 teaspoons black pepper
  • 2 tablespoons oregano flakes
  • 1/4 cup minced parsley
  • 1/4 cup brown sugar or unrefined cane sugar

Directions

Wash 30 pounds of tomatoes. Remove cores and quarter tomatoes.

Cook 20 minutes, uncovered, in large pan or pans to soften tomatoes. I cook mine at a strong simmer in an assortment of heavy bottom stainless steel pans. I have also used a Nesco roaster.

Thick bottom pans prevent accidental scorching, frequent stirring is recommended. Don't use aluminum – it will react with the acid in the tomatoes. When I cook on the stove top, I start with four pans and cook the sauce down to one 8 quart stockpot.

cooking down tomatoes in a Nesco roaster for homemade marinara sauce

Put tomatoes through a food strainer or food mill. I have a Back to Basics food strainer that works beautifully. (The Back to Basics strainer isn't available anymore, but this Norpro strainer is similar.)

Years ago I used a chinois strainer, and I still use it for small batches, but for large batches the food strainer can't be beat. It's so much faster!

using a food strainer to remove seeds and skins from tomatoes

Cook down tomatoes to reduce volume and make a thicker sauce. We start with four pots and end up with one. This is the base of your spaghetti sauce.

stock pot filled with tomato sauce cooking down

While the tomato sauce is cooking, you can do the rest of the prep work, like chopping the rest of your veggies, filling the canner, and getting the lids and jars ready.

My pressure canner uses three quarts of water, to which I add one tablespoon of white vinegar to reduce hard water build up on the jars. I wash my jars in the dishwasher and keep them hot until I'm ready to fill.

I keep my lids in hot water in a one quart saucepan (do not boil lids), and use kitchen tongs for lifting them out of the water. The latest generation of canning lids from Ball do not require preheating, but I have a stock of lids that I am still working through.

To Finish the Spaghetti Sauce for Canning

Saute in 1/4 cup butter or olive oil until tender: onions, garlic, celery or green pepper, and mushrooms. Combine sauteed vegetables and tomatoes. Add salt, black pepper, oregano, parsley and sugar.

Bring to a boil. Stir frequently to avoid burning. Reduce heat to simmer, keep hot while waiting to process.

Canning the Spaghetti Sauce

Fill jars, leaving 1 inch headspace. Adjust lids. Process in a pressure canner 20 minutes for pints, 25 minutes for quarts.

If using a weighted-gauge canner, set at 10 pounds pressure at 0-1,000 feet above sea level; set at 15 pounds pressure at higher altitudes.

If using a dial-gauge canner; set at:

  • 11 pounds pressure at 0-2000 feet above sea level
  • 12 pounds at 2,001-4,000 feet
  • 13 pounds at 4,001-6,000 feet
  • 14 pounds at 6.001-8,000 feet
  • 15 pounds above 8,000 feet

Allow canner to cool and release pressure. Remove jars and set on towel on counter. Let rest until cool, or overnight.

Remove rings, wipe any spills. Date and label and store in a cool, dry location, out of direct sunlight. Best used within 1-2 years.

Yields around eight pints of home canned spaghetti sauce.

home canned spaghetti sauce in mason jars with tomatoes in background

How long does home canned spaghetti sauce last?

The flavor and nutrient levels in your home canned spaghetti sauce are best when used within one to two years. If you store the sauce in the freezer, try to use it within six months.

We've used a few home canned items at five years of age, but the flavor is not as good.

Never use a canned product with a broken seal, bulging lid or other obvious signs of damage or spoilage.

How do you thicken homemade spaghetti sauce for canning?

Low, slow cooking is my default option to thicken the sauce and concentrate the flavor of the tomatoes. Other options include:

  • Weigh and freeze the tomatoes, and then allow them to thaw in a colander to remove excess liquid before proceeding with the recipe.
  • Can the sauce when it is somewhat thin, and then add tomato powder or dehydrated tomato puree to thicken when you heat the sauce for serving. I use this option when I make sauce out of cherry tomatoes or other very juicy tomatoes instead of paste tomatoes.

Some people grind up the skins and seeds to thicken the sauce. For our tastes, this made the sauce so bitter that we couldn't eat it.

If You Don't Have Enough Ripe Tomatoes from One Picking

If you don't have enough ripe tomatoes at one time for canning spaghetti sauce, you can pop tomatoes that are very ripe or damaged into the freezer, until you have enough for the recipe.

I have found that ripe, undamaged tomatoes will easily keep for a week or more at room temperature. Cracked or otherwise damaged tomatoes will only last a day or two before spoiling and/or attracting fruit flies, so they should be processed in some manner within 24 hours, if possible.

I usually core the tomatoes and half or quarter them (depending on the size) before freezing. Then, when I am planning on canning spaghetti sauce the next day, I place them in the sink overnight to thaw. In the morning, you can pour off some of the clear juice if you like so that the cook down quicker. Weigh them out, dump them into your stockpot, and start cooking.

If you have fruit that's refusing to ripen, check out “4 Reasons your Tomatoes Aren’t Ripening – And What You can Do About it“. If you have tomato blossoms, but no fruit, we have help for that, too.

Recommended Equipment for Canning Spaghetti Sauce:

Print

Home Canned Spaghetti Sauce

canning spaghetti sauce
Print Recipe

★★★★★

5 from 5 reviews

Never buy spaghetti sauce from the store again.This homemade canning spaghetti sauce recipe is slow cooked and loaded with flavor. May also be used fresh or frozen if you don't have a pressure canner.

  • Prep Time: 5 hours
  • Cook Time: 20 minutes
  • Total Time: 5 hours 20 minutes
  • Yield: 8 pints 1x
  • Category: Sauce
  • Method: Canning
  • Cuisine: American-Italian

Ingredients

Scale
  • 30 pounds tomatoes
  • 1/4 cup butter or olive oil
  • 1 cup chopped onions
  • 5 minced garlic cloves
  • 2 tablespoons salt
  • 1 cup chopped celery or green pepper
  • 1 pound sliced mushrooms (optional)
  • 2 teaspoons black pepper
  • 2 tablespoons dried oregano flakes
  • 1/4 cup minced parsley
  • 1/4 cup brown sugar or unrefined cane sugar

Instructions

  1. Wash 30 pounds of tomatoes. Remove cores and quarter tomatoes. Boil 20 minutes, uncovered, in large pan (or pans).
  2. Put through food strainer or food mill. Cook down tomatoes to reduce volume and make a thicker sauce. Reduce volume by 1/2 to 2/3rds.
  3. While the sauce is cooking, finish the remaining prep work, like chopping your veggies and getting the lids and jars ready. Prepare pressure canner according to manufacturer's instructions.

To Finish the Sauce

  1. Saute in 1/4 cup butter or olive oil until tender: onions, garlic, celery or green pepper, and mushrooms.
  2. Combine sauteed vegetables and tomatoes.
  3. Add salt, black pepper, oregano, parsley and sugar.
  4. Bring to a boil. Stir frequently to avoid burning. Reduce heat to simmer, keep hot while waiting to process.
  5. Fill jars, leaving 1 inch headspace. Adjust lids.
  6. Process in a pressure canner 20 minutes for pints, 25 minutes for quarts. If using a weighted-gauge canner, set at 10 pounds pressure at 0-1,000 feet above sea level; set at 15 pounds pressure at higher altitudes. If using a dial-gauge canner; set at 11 pounds pressure at 0-2000 feet above sea level; 12 pounds at 2,001-4,000 feet; 13 pounds at 4,001-6,000 feet; 14 pounds at 6.001-8,000 feet; or 15 pounds above 8,000 feet.
  7. Allow canner to cool and release pressure. Remove jars and set on towel on counter. Let rest until cool, or overnight. Remove rings, wipe any spills. Date and label and store in a cool, dry location, out of direct sunlight. Best used within 1-2 years.

Nutrition

  • Serving Size: 1 cup

Keywords: spaghetti sauce, marinara, tomato sauce, canning

Did you make this recipe?

Share a photo and tag us — we can't wait to see what you've made!

You may also enjoy:

Originally published in 2009, last updated in 2019.

Similar Posts

Dandelion Jelly – Easy Flower Jelly Recipe with Less Sugar
|

Dandelion Jelly – Easy Flower Jelly Recipe with Less Sugar

ByLaurie Neverman

This easy dandelion jelly recipe uses less sugar than most flower jelly recipes, creating a light and delicious jelly. To make your dandelion jelly, you’ll need dandelion blossoms, water, lemon juice, sugar, Pomona’s Pectin and calcium water. (Calcium water is included in every box of Pomona’s Pectin). I like this recipe because it has no…

How to Make Elderberry Wine and Identify Wild Elderberry Bushes
|

How to Make Elderberry Wine and Identify Wild Elderberry Bushes

ByLaurie Neverman

How to make elderberry wine – it’s something I’ve wondered about since watching Monty Python’s Quest for the Holy Grail many years ago. 🙂 (“Your mother was a hamster, and your father smelt of elderberries.”) It turns out that making homemade elderberry wine is pretty easy, as long as you have elderberries. If you don’t…

154 Comments

  1. Good tutorials on both the spaget sauce and salsa! I've been making and freezing "raw" tomatoe soup and sauce – sure glad those 'maters made it before the frost nailed the garden!

    Reply

    1. My question is if I could core the tomatoes and get the seeds out that way and than puree them in a food processor?

      Reply

      1. It’s a lot easier to cook them up and then run them through a food strainer, food mill or chinois than to hand remove the seeds, but if you really wanted to, you could blanch the tomatoes to remove the skins, core them and seed them and then cook them down and run them through a food processor. Alternatively, you could core them, seed them and skip blanching, and just grind up the peels, too. Some people even skip removing the seeds – but I find them quite bitter and unpleasant when pureed.

        Reply

        1. I’ve been doing the same as you Laurie for quite a few years now, it is the best way the sauce comes out smoother and better flavor. Keep up the good canning

          Reply

    1. Do you not use lemon juice or citric acid? I thought you always have to with high acid foods like tomatoes. Thanks!

      Reply

        1. Thanks so much. I have been looking for a while for a pressure canned tomato recipe that does not require adding acid. The reason often given is that no one has bothered to test tomatoes pressure canned and there is no money to do that, so just follow the water bath recipes. This makes no sense, as I can do green beans and other foods with much lower acid than tomatoes without a problem in the pressure canner.

          I also like the explanation for removing seeds. All the recipes say to remove them, but never say why. Bitterness was not something I ever thought of.

          Reply

          1. The seeds also raise the pH slightly, but with pressure canning that’s not an issue.

            This recipe is adapted from the one on the National Center for Home Food Preservation website (same ingredients, more detailed instructions), so it has been tested.

  3. Most days it smells pretty good, I must admit. That's one of my favorite parts of cooking and one of my favorite things to come home to after a day in town. :^)

    Reply

  4. Laurie, I am loving your posts! Just the inspiration I am needing! Those tomatoes look fabulous and I can just smell the sauce. I am growing more tomatoes next year. *Ü*

    Reply

    1. So here’s my question for you. I don’t currently have a pressure canner. And I’ve made tomato sauce before with the lemon juice and it didn’t personally bother me. If I were to add the lemon juice to each jar would it be safe to can this in a water bath? I know you don’t like the lemon flavor but from a safety standpoint what are your thoughts?

      Reply

      1. I can’t recommend that because it would be difficult to ensure uniform acidity in the jar. It would be safer to freeze the sauce. If you want to try it and pH test the sauce, that’s up to you.

        Reply

  5. Michelle, some of my favorite paste varieties are Amish Paste, Opalka and Purple Russian. For me, one or more of these three will produce large, meaty fruit and lots of them no matter what the weather conditions. My favorite seed sources are on the sidebar. It takes time to do this, but the technique is easy and the flavor is outstanding.

    Reply

    1. I do not have the answer but I have my tom already throught food processor, so how much do I need for 30 lbs of tomatoes

      Reply

      1. I really don’t know. I always measure by starting tomato weight. Before I cook them down, there are around 21 quarts of quartered tomatoes, but I’ve never attempted to use a food processor, or measure them mid-processing.

        Reply

  7. What, no Basil in your pasta sauce? 🙂

    I keep looking back at this recipe, and after making a couple of batches of tomato sauce (not this recipe unfortunately as we just don't have that many tomatoes in our little garden) I wonder about the food ratios; you mention that "It is not safe to increase the proportion of onions, peppers, celery or mushrooms in this recipe if you are planning to can the sauce …" but you reduce the amount of tomatoes considerably during the entire process. Is this what you expect of the volume of tomatoes to vegetables?

    Reply

  8. Glenn, believe it or not, I'm not a huge fan of basil. I use it pretty sparingly in the kitchen. You could probably sub it in for the mushrooms or any of the other non-acidic ingredients.

    As for the tomato ratio and safety issues, the quote was from the original recipe. What I believe she wanted to avoid was people overloading the sauce with other ingredients and losing the acidity of the tomatoes. You're only driving off excess water, not really changing the proportions, when you cook the tomatoes down, with or without the other veggies. Either should increase the acidity of the end product. If one was to add an extremely high proportion of non-acidic ingredients, you could potentially create a low-acid environment that would be much more prone to spoilage. I don't think tweaking a bit this way or that would be a problem, but some people go overboard. If it's really a concern one could use a pH test on the final product before canning and add some lemon juice or vinegar to lower the acidity if needed.

    Reply

    2. I thought you could base your canning times and pressure on the lowest acid ingredient in the recipe and maintain a safe product. More onions you would base the times and pressures on canning onions, etc

      Reply

      1. While basing processing times on the lowest acid ingredient may by effective, other factors may be at work, like thickness of product. Given the wide range of skill levels of people using recipes on the site, I try to keep things as simple as possible.

        Reply

      1. Personally, I most assuredly do taste it, and think it tastes terrible, which is why I’ve switched to non-GMO citric acid for plain tomato sauce. If you or anyone else decides to add lemon juice to this recipe, please do a pH test before attempting water bath canning.

        Reply

    1. Water bath canning is not recommended for this sauce because the additional ingredients (other than tomatoes) raise the pH of the final product to a level where water bath canning is considered unsafe.

      Reply

  13. So glad I found this recipe! I plan to make some spaghetti sauce tomorrow (already have a “killer” recipe for salsa 🙂 Thank you!

    Reply

  15. Laurie, I just went over the entire recipe but I cannot find the recipe for the salsa, did I miss it? Can you share (email) it with me and the stewed tomatoes? Thank you

    Reply

    1. The link to the salsa is in the text right about the photo of finished jars, but I’ll make it to see because if you can’t see it, other can’t, either. Here’s the link to the salsa recipe: https://commonsensehome.com/home-canned-salsa/

      For the stewed tomatoes, I followed the Blue Book directions. Peel the tomatoes and put them in a large pot. Heat to quite warm ( no need to boil, you just don’t want to put cold food in hot jars). Add 1 tablespoon lemon juice to each pine, 2 tablespoons to each quart jar. This makes sure that the tomatoes are acidic enough to safely can, as many modern varieties are less acidic. Pack tomatoes into hot jars. Poke are press down with a wooden spoon or chopstick to make sure the air is out. Leave 1/2 inch headspace. Add 1/2 teaspoon salt per pint, 1 teaspoon salt per quart. (Optional). Put on lids and process pints and quarts 1 hour and 25 minutes in a boiling water bath or 25 minutes at 10 pounds pressure in a pressure canner.

      Reply

  16. hi there, question-
    back in the day canning tomatoes was just tomatoes,.salt, sugar and we used basil. all fresh and in water bath. no vinegar, lemon juice or citric acid. a recent glance at ball book spaghetti sauce recipe online and a number of other on line recipes say to use either one of those w the recipe it gives. more research and we read todays genetically modified tomatoes need citric acid, vinegar or lemon juice for canning. whats ur experience on this?
    thanks 🙂

    Reply

    1. As far as I know, there are not currently any genetically modified tomatoes on the market – however – most modern hybrids are lower in acidity than traditional heirloom varieties. With the addition of herbs and/or other vegetables, this could place your tomato based sauce into the low acid range, making it a candidate for botulism or other food borne illness. Thus, the addition of lemon or vinegar to most current tomato sauce recipes.

      Reply

    1. Yes, that agrees with my understanding. Better safe than sorry, as we deal with nastier bugs than they did in the past.

      Thank you for your words of encouragement. Some days it’s tough to find the energy to tackle it all. The kind words help keep me motivated.

      Reply

  20. Hi, sounds wonderful! I can my tomatoes only. Any way you can break your reciepe down for a pint of tomatoes?
    Thanks!

    Reply

    1. It’d be an awful lot of work to fire up the canner for a pint of anything, but you could divide all the measurements roughly be 12 if you just wanted to make it to eat right away.

      Reply

  21. I admit I did not read all the previous comments – just a quick scan. I was just wondering if it would be safe to remove the sugar from the recipe?

    Reply

  22. Finally found THE recipe! It was well worth the time involved. I got 9 pints. I wish it wasn’t so late in the season so there would be enough tomatoes to make another batch!!!!! Planning for next year….

    Reply

  23. I’m just wondering why you use so many pots and don’t try using an electric roaster? It sure cuts down on the extra work.

    Reply

  24. Since this is pressure canned, the ratio of veggies will not affect safe acidity levels; that is only an issue with water bath canning. I am hoping to have a good crop of tomatoes this year and will try this recipe. I’m still on the look out for a great tasting speghetti sauce recipe. thanks.

    Reply

      1. We add a lot more onions and and garlic to our 30 lbs of tomatoes and more spices too. We do add a tablespoon of lemon juice to each quart jar and have never had a problem with spoilage.

        Reply

  25. Hello thanks so much for the recipe. Planning on making this tonight but had a couple questions. I didn’t read anything about removing the skins. Should I leave them on? Also can I process themm in a magic bullet and just leave the seeds in my sauce? Thanks.

    Reply

    1. The seeds are removed with the food strainer (“Put through large food mill or sieve.” ) – fourth photo on page.

      There are websites out there that will recommend pureeing seeds and skins in a high powered blender, but I’m not one of them. I tried it – once. The result was an incredibly bitter, basically inedible sauce. It was foul. Skins alone might not be quite as bad, but if you’re straining seeds you might as well strain skins, too.

      Reply

  26. Hey Laurie, I love the recipe, but have a question: Is there a reason that you cook the tomatoes down for the 20 mins before straining out the skins and seeds? Why not just chop them and put them through the strainer before beginning the cooking process? Just wondering if there was a specific reason?

    Reply

      1. I did the same thing. I used the traditional canning recipe and added Parmesean (because I normally add Parmesean, I did it without even checking the recipe). Now, I’m wondering what to do with all of this sauce. I had already canned 6 quarts before it occurred to me. Can I freeze the sauce with Parmesean?

        Reply

    1. I wouldn’t recommend it, but if you did it and tested the pH and it was below 4.6, it should be safe. That much lemon would really make the taste less pleasant. The sauce can also be frozen if you don’t have a pressure canner.

      Reply

  29. My family brings the processed tomatoes to a boil and then places them in sterilized jars. The lids are simultaneously boiling in water and are pulled out one by one and placed on the jars, topped off with a ring. The heated lids form the seal then with the heat from the tomatoes. We only put the jars in water if the tomatoes were not very hot.

    Reply

    1. Lots of families process tomatoes the same way. My mom did that years ago. Unfortunately, with the more deadly microbes we have now, a better understanding of food science, and the higher pH of many modern tomato varieties, it is no longer recommended for safety reasons.

      Reply

  30. Hi there Laurie,
    I’m not sure if I’ve shared this with you before but I apologize if I have.
    So, one year I had a HUGE crop of ‘maters and no time to prep and can them. So I rinsed them, and froze them whole. Then that winter I had to figure out what I was going to do with all these frozen tomatoes. I had wanted fire roasted tomatoes like the ones from Muir Glen. But grilling tomatoes is a thankless and wasteful job. Luckily, I discovered that if you take the frozen whole tomatoes out of the freezer and set them on the counter for 45 minutes, they are then barely soft enough to cut in half. Take the frozen halves and lay them face up on a cooling rack set over a sheet pan and put in a 350 degree oven for one hour. The only caution I would share is all the water will be in the sheet pan so use extreme caution pulling them out of the oven. (I cool the water and give to my plants or pour over my dogs food) So now I have roasted halves of tomatoes. I let them cool a bit and then gingerly pick them up by the underside and using clean hands of course, squeeze the meat out into a dish and what’s left is either the skin (on the bottom half of the tomato) or the skin and stem (on the top half). I then give the skins and stems to my chickens who are VERY happy to get this bounty.
    What I have is a lovely roasted tomato puree that needs only a bit of salt and herbs to make marinara sauce. No need for paste or hours of cooking. You should try it sometime. It really is a great way to make marinara sauce. And I just water bath canned them. I would love to hear what you think about this method as I literally stumbled upon it trying to figure out how to deal with bags of frozen whole tomatoes one year. I have never seen anyone else do this so….
    Anyway, Thanks again,
    Pam

    Reply

    1. I don’t think you shared this before, or if you did, I can’t recall. I’d probably freeze, dry or freeze dry the resulting sauce, because tomatoes can be right on the edge of the current guidelines for safe water bath canning in terms of pH. The current recommendations called for added lemon or citric acid to canned tomato juice, tomatoes and sauces, which affects the flavor quite a bit (to me). if you did some pH testing and made sure it was below 4.6, then you’d know for sure you were out of botulism land.

      It sounds tasty.

      Reply

  31. Do you have a brand or type of pressure canner you recommend? We did hot water bath canning last year but have 16 tomato plants and want to try doing sauce this year.

    Reply

    1. I have two Presto units, a Presto 01781 23-Quart Pressure Canner and Cooker that I use for larger jobs. I take the rack from my other unit, and can use it between pint jars to stack two layers high. I also picked up a Presto 01745 16-Quart pressure Canner and Cooker a few years ago, because the smaller vessel cycles a little faster with small batches. Both work well and get the job done.

      My dream canner would be the All American 921 21-1/2-Quart Pressure Cooker/Canner, which has a metal on metal seal (no rubber gasket), and is made to last a lifetime – possibly several lifetimes.

      Reply

  32. I have already finished my canning this year, but for future canning… if you leave out the mushrooms, is it safe to increase the other non-acidic ingredients (onion, celery, bell pepper)? It seems logical to me, but haven’t found any guidelines to confirm. And if so, would the safe amount of increase (onions, celery, bell peppers) be 1 lb. total? I don’t see any good reason to add the mushrooms to the sauce before canning, since the finished product will be used in a variety of ways, and I can always add mushrooms before serving, if desired.

    Reply

  33. How many cups of puree should I get? It seems that starting with lbs there could be some variation in the ratios,

    Reply

  34. Hi Laurie, I’m new to canning and I’d love to try this recipe. Can I use fresh oregano instead of dried? I have more oregano in my garden this year than I know what to do with. ????

    Reply

  35. Good morning,
    I stumbled across your tomato sauce recipe and am making a batch now. I had a bushel of Roma tomato’s and the end weight is around 38 lbs. I eliminated the mushrooms and had several tablespoons over the 1 cup of both green peppers and onions not much though. I am wondering if you have heard of or have tried using canned tomato paste to thicken your sauce. Also I would like to add dried basil would that alter the recipe?

    Reply

    1. Dried basil should be fine, as should a small amount of tomato paste or powder. Just don’t get the consistency too thick, or that will impair heat transfer and could lead to unsafe canning conditions.

      Reply

  37. HI, New at canning and diabetic, eat Low Carb HIgh Fat. Can I leave out the sugar or sub a natural sweetner like stevia?

    Reply

    1. I don’t have one on the site. To safely water bath can tomatoes, you need to add lemon juice, which changes the flavor, or citric acid, which has less impact on flavor. You can safely water bath can plain tomato sauce by adding 1 tablespoon lemon juice per pint (2 tablespoons per quart). Process pints 35 minutes and quarts 40 minutes in a water bath canner.

      Reply

      1. I have only canned using a water bath. Do I understand correctly that I can use your recipe just add 1 Tbsp lemon juice to pint prior to filling and processing? Any idea if canning jars can be used in Instant Pot? I understand that to be a pressure cooker. Thanks, Rose.

        Reply

        1. While I understand that some individuals may seek to limit their salt intake for a variety of reasons, calling salt “poison” is inaccurate.

          In the article “Salt is Essential to Life” from the University of Hawaii, they note:

          Salt plays a crucial role in maintaining human health. It is the main source of sodium and chloride ions in the human diet. Sodium is essential for nerve and muscle function and is involved in the regulation of fluids in the body. Sodium also plays a role in the body’s control of blood pressure and volume. …

          Chloride ions serve as important electrolytes by regulating blood pH and pressure. Electrolytes are compounds, often salts, which dissociate into their ionic components in solvents like water. Chloride is also a crucial component in the production of stomach acid (HCl). Humans excrete salt when sweating and must replenish these lost sodium and chloride ions through their diet.

          Reply

  41. My sauce is extremely runny despite cooking it down forever. Is it safe to add cornstarch to thicken prior to canning? I might add that some of my tomatoes were previously frozen and some were fresh. It measured about 30+ pounds. And if I omit the mushrooms do I have to add another cup of peppers, celery, or onions?

    Reply

    1. You don’t need to add addition peppers, celery or onions.

      If all you have available for thickening is corn starch, it’s better to wait to thicken until after canning. Corn starch may clump during canning. A better alternative is UltraGel or ClearGel, which is specifically made not to clump during canning.

      Reply

        1. You’re welcome. We need to tackle garden chores and cleaning this afternoon (our open house is coming up soon), but I know others are working on weekend projects, too.

          Another option for thickening is plain tomato powder, which you can buy in bulk. I usually order Frontier organic tomato powder (amazon link). Sometimes I add very finely shredded dehydrated zucchini, too. It crumbles up and dissolves right into the sauce. More on that here – https://commonsensehome.com/extra-zucchini/

          If I use all paste tomatoes, the sauce turns out thicker. With a mix of tomato types, or if the weather has been rainy, it’s tough to get it as thick as we prefer with just cooking it down.

          Reply

  42. Hi there.
    So I’m interested in trying your recipe but I would love to add olives without decreasing the other vegetables. I understand that this would offset the approved acidic level that you have. What would I need to do to bring it back into balance? More tomatoes? Longer processing time? And thoughts or suggestions?

    Thank you.

    Reply

    1. Add them when you heat the sauce for serving? That would be the simplest. With pressure canning, there is some wiggle room in the pH (because it’s used with low acid foods), but I’m hesitant to make specific recommendations because your sauce might be thicker or thinner, or… You can probably add a cup or so, but I sure as heck don’t want to be responsible for someone mixing up something that get’s them sick.

      The big thing to watch for is that you don’t get whatever your canning so thick that it can’t move freely in the jar. (Pumpkin butter, for instance, is not recommended for canning, but pumpkin chunks in water are fine because the water can circulate the heat.)

      Reply

  44. Does the size of the chopped mushrooms or celery or onion make a difference? Could they be pulverized with an immersion blender to “hide” them from my kids but still have the taste?

    Reply

    1. As long as it takes to get the sauce to your desired thickness. This will vary depending on the moisture content of your tomatoes, your stove, your cooking pots and how frequently you stir. As I mentioned in the post, I start out cooking multiple pots, but when the spaghetti sauce is ready to process, it all fits in an eight quart stock pot.

      Reply

  46. My tomato sauces are alw as ys so watery or thin. Is there anything I can do? What could I be doing wrong? How long do you cook your tomatoes?

    ★★★★★

    Reply

    1. For a thicker sauce, it really helps to start with very meaty paste tomatoes. Without paste tomatoes, I end up cooking it down for most of the day.

      Another “cheat” you can use to thicken your sauce is adding tomato paste or tomato powder, but I normally add that after canning, when I go to use the sauce, if needed. (Sometimes I end up making sauce with whatever tomatoes are left in the garden, or using up cherry tomatoes so they don’t go to waste.)

      I like Frontier organic tomato powder, but there are other options available. Sometimes I make tomato puree and dehydrate it, and then add chunks of the dehydrated puree to thicken my sauce when getting ready to serve it.

      Reply

      1. Oh – dried, very finely shredded zucchini can also be used to thicken the sauce and sneak in more veggies (when you’re getting ready to serve, not before canning), but of course it doesn’t add more tomato flavor.

        Reply

  48. Do I need to add all the oil and sugar? Doing WW and don’t really need the extra points in my sauce. Also, can I add more spices or is that a no-no.

    Reply

    1. Dry spices are okay in small amounts. Skipping the oil is okay. The sugar does help to act as a preservative and balances the flavors, but it should be okay without it.

      Reply

  49. I don’t have enough paste tomatoes this year for the recipe. Any suggestions on where I can purchase them or good substitutes?

    Reply

    1. You can use any tomatoes you have available. Paste tomatoes just require less cook time to make a thicker sauce.

      Are their any farmers markets or local vegetable growers of any sort in your area? Around here, there are some who will take bulk orders for produce, especially if you are willing to take fruit with small cosmetic imperfections that don’t sell well at market, but work just fine in sauce.

      If there are no local fresh tomatoes to be found, you can used gallon cans of whole tomatoes. Just check the weight on the can and plan accordingly.

      Reply

  51. Way too complicated and no you don’t need to pressure can this.
    Use lemon juice and no it doesn’t change the flavour of the sauce.

    Reply

    1. Jay – you’re not the one who could be held liable if someone ended up sick or dead from questionable canning practices. Millions of people visit this site for SAFE canning advice every year. I take that responsibility very seriously. I’ll stick with tested recipes. I spent a months growing beautiful tomatoes. A few more minutes in the kitchen for another year of SAFE food in my pantry is worth it to me.

      Yes, some of us can taste the lemon juice, to the point where it ruins the sauce. Not everyone tastes it. Some people grind up the skins and seeds too, and keep them in the sauce. I tried that once, and had to toss the sauce out in the compost because it tasted vile. People have different perceptions of taste. It’s not a “one size fits all” sort of thing.

      Reply

  52. I’ve made, and canned, a version of this recipe for many many years. If you try to water bath anything that has garlic or onions in it you are setting yourself up to get really sick. Used a pressure canner, it is not rocket science

    ★★★★★

    Reply
  54. Pingback: 4 Reasons Your Tomatoes Are Not Ripening + How You Can Help

    1. Seems I read a pressure canner should be used not a pressure cooker,? Is there a difference between the 2?

      Reply

      1. Pressure canners are specifically designed for canning. The are big enough to fit canning jars into them, and have a rack in the bottom to keep those jars off the bottom of the canner. Some pressure canners may also be used for cooking, bu pressure cookers aren’t generally used for canning.

        Reply
  55. Pingback: Home Canned Salsa Recipe - Plus 10 Tips for Canning Salsa Safely
  57. Pingback: Grow Tomatoes from Seed - Save Money, Get More Varieties

  58. I know that canning beef/chicken has been done safely for decades. My question is can I add ground beef and or sausage and still safely pressure can it?

    Reply

    1. Yes. Use 2 and half pounds of ground beef or sausage and add with the vegetables.

      Processing times increase significantly.

      From the National Center for Home Food Preservation Spaghetti Sauce with Meat recipe:

      Dial gauge canner – process pints 60 minutes and quarts 70 minutes at 11 pounds pressure

      Weighted-gauge canner – process pints 60 minutes and quarts 70 minutes at 10 pounds of pressure

      (They have altitude adjustments on the site for higher elevations.)

      Reply

  59. Laurie, Thanks so much for your safe canning recipes and advice. I never want to take any chances when I don’t have to. I’ve cored, quartered, and frozen lots of tomatoes this season as they got ripe. Now that I’ve taken them out of the freezer I weighed them. Since I didn’t weigh them before I cored them, is it still about 30 pounds that I would use for your recipe?

    Reply

    1. Hi Beverly.

      Not weighing before coring is not an issue, because you’ll end up with a bit more tomato. Adding extra ingredients with low pH (like tomato or vinegar) still keeps the recipe safe. Extra non-acidic ingredients are risky.

      Reply

  61. Ms Neverman.. you have to have descended directly from Job..from the bible..I know of no other who could or would answer the very same question…over and over and over again. God Bless you…and thank you for teaching me something today. I was gonna do my first canning of marinara sauce for the winter. I too, was gonna water can it with lemon juice..I don’t have a pressure cooker..and not a bunch of freezer room…THANK YOU FOR THE HEADS UP…instead.. I am just gonna can the tomatoes and make the sauce after I open the can of tomatoes. Did I read it correctly…that you can water can the tomatoes safety add the one tablespoon of lemon juice and then process for 40 mins quarts 35 pints? Do you taste the lemon in just the tomatoes..or upon completing the sauce you can add enough ingredients to cover up the lemon taste.? Thank you so much for your time..and your patience. Lord knows I don’t have any! Maybe you got my portion also?? Lol.. Blessings

    Reply

    1. Hi Scott.

      Thanks for your patience. I was working in the garden earlier today and had to run to town this afternoon to get critter food, so am just now catching up online.

      For full tomato canning instructions, see “How to Can Tomatoes in a Canner or Large Pot“. I do taste the lemon juice, some people don’t.

      If you want to keep the flavor more neutral, you can get non-GMO citric acid online (or regular citric acid if you don’t mind GMOs).

      Use 1/2 teaspoon citric acid powder per quart, 1/4 teaspoon per pint.

      Reply
  62. Pingback: Home Canned Tomato Soup - Easy Recipe for Canning Tomato Soup
  63. Pingback: Tomatillo Salsa (Salsa Verde) Recipe with Instructions for Safe Canning
  64. Pingback: 2 Homemade Ketchup Recipes - One for Canning, One Probiotic
  65. Pingback: How to Can Tomatoes in a Canner or Large Pot - Easy Instructions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆