Cozy Mulled Apple Cider with Flavor Variations

This post may contain affiliate links. Read my full disclosure here.

Few things say “cozy” like a steaming mug of mulled apple cider on a crisp fall day. The aroma of spices and apples fills the house while the cider gently simmers, making it a seasonal favorite. I’ll take a pot of simmering cider over commercial “air freshener” any day of the week.

Here’s how to make your own mulled cider and a simple recipe for mulling spices, with a few variations to suit your taste.

Basic Mulled Apple Cider Recipe
Homemade Mulling Spice Mix

Basic Mulled Apple Cider Recipe

This simple recipe lets you turn apple cider into a cozy, spiced drink that’s perfect for sharing—or treating yourself. Heat on the stove top or in the slow cooker. Pair with maple leaf cookies for fall gatherings.

Ingredients:

1 gallon apple cider (not apple juice)
1/4 cup homemade mulling spice mix (see below)
1 orange, sliced (optional) or dried orange slices
Sweetener to taste (maple syrup, honey, or sugar), optional

Directions:

Combine cider, spices, and orange slices in a large pot or slow cooker.
Simmer on low heat for around 30 minutes (60 for slow cookers) to allow flavors to infuse. Avoid boiling, which can make cider taste bitter.
Strain spices and fruit before serving.
Serve in mugs, piping hot, garnished with a cinnamon stick, twist of orange peel, or apple slices.

Feel free to adjust batch size as needed. For instance:

1 tablespoon of mulling spices in 1 quart of cider for a small batch
1 1/2 teaspoons of spices for one pint cider for a single serving
1/2 cup mulling spice for two gallons of cider

Homemade Mulling Spice Mix

This mix makes about 1 cup, enough for 3–4 gallons of cider.

Ingredients:

1/2 cup broken cinnamon sticks
1/4 cup whole cloves
1/4 cup allspice berries
1/4 cup dried orange peel
2 tablespoons dried ginger pieces

Would you like to save this?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

To Use:
Add about 1/4 cup per gallon of cider. Place in a muslin bag or tea strainer for easy removal.

Flavor Variations

Cranberry Twist – Add dried cranberries (or cranberry juice) and a touch of star anise. This gives a tart, slightly floral flavor that pairs beautifully with holiday meals. Star anise al so looks festive floating in the cider.
Vanilla Spice – Slip in a split vanilla bean with the spice mix. The vanilla rounds out the sharpness of cloves and adds a mellow sweetness.
Spicy Kick – Add 1–2 dried chili peppers or a pinch of black peppercorns. The heat complements the natural sweetness of cider.
Woodland Blend – Include juniper berries and a sprig or two of rosemary. This creates a piney, herbal note reminiscent of winter forests. (To me, rosemary tastes like eating a Christmas tree, but I bet my friend MaryJean would love this.)

Work with what you have on hand. You can substitute fresh ginger or cranberries for dried, or add your favorite fruit or herbs. Pomegranate seeds are another good addition for a pop of color and flavor.

Tips for the Best Mulled Cider

Use fresh cider: Look for local, unpasteurized cider if available—it has the richest flavor. We have a cider press and make our own, too, but sometimes I let others tackle pressing. I’ve noticed different local orchards have different flavor profiles for their ciders.
Don’t overheat: Keep the heat low. High heat can burn off aromatics and give cider a scorched taste. I use a SimmerMat heat diffuser on my stove burner for even heating.
Make ahead: Mulled cider holds well in a slow cooker on the “warm” setting for hours, making it perfect for parties.
Double-duty spices: After straining, reuse the spices once more in a smaller batch or in simmering potpourri.
Try it chilled: While normally served hot, leftover mulled cider is delicious cooled and served over ice the next day. You can also turn leftover mulled cider into finger gelatin.

FAQ

What’s the difference between apple juice and apple cider?

In the U.S., cider usually means unsweetened, unfiltered apple juice, while “apple juice” is filtered and shelf-stable. For mulled drinks, cider’s fuller body and natural sweetness work best. You can use juice if you don’t have cider available.

Can I make mulled cider without whole spices?

Yes, you can substitute ground spices, but they won’t strain out cleanly. If you only have ground spices, tie them in a coffee filter or add sparingly to avoid grit.

If you’re a mulled apple cider fan, I suggest buying bulk mulling spices, like this Frontier Co-op mix. Store unused portion in an airtight container – there’s enough to share with friends, too.

Can mulled cider be made in advance?

Yes. Store cooled cider in the refrigerator for 2–3 days, then reheat gently. The flavor may deepen after resting.

Is mulled cider alcoholic?

Traditional mulled cider is non-alcoholic. If you’d like, you can add a splash of rum, bourbon, or brandy just before serving. (My vote is for rum or brandy.)

Can I use this mulling spice for other drinks?

Absolutely. It works in red wine, cranberry juice, or even black tea for a warming twist. Try it with homemade blackberry or elderberry wine.

Wrapping Up

Mulled apple cider is a timeless way to enjoy the harvest and bring warmth into your home during cool months. With a homemade spice mix, you can adjust flavors to suit your family. It also creates a comforting tradition that makes your house smell wonderful, too.